I have been going to Identity for 4 years and I would see Karissa. She is really sweet, but frankly the last few times I went to her, she did not do a good job with my ombre hair color. She also charged me $40 for a hair cut when she cut off literally 1/4" of hair and had to re-tone my hair for the ombre, and I still did not get the color I had requested. Additionally, I had seen another stylist when she was on maternity leave, who the salon stated was the only other person to do ombre color, and this woman completely and utterly botched my hair. She had no idea how to color dark hair and completely bleached out my hair without giving me the color that I wanted. She also completely misplaced the highlights and it looked as though some beauty school trainee had done my hair. When I called the salon the same day, I spoke with the Salon manager and she told me I could come in and have the same woman fix my hair. However, the next day, I called back because I did not trust the same stylist to fix my hair, and I spoke with the Spa manager who was very understanding and said that she could not provide me with a refund, but that she would place a gift card for the full service amount ($145) at the front desk for the next time I came in and saw Karissa once she was back. I went to another salon and spent another $100 just to get it fixed - and fixed did not mean get the look I wanted. She basically dyed over the color to cover the poorly placed highlights and toned down the hair color.
When Karissa came back, I asked her to give me the same ombre hair color that she normally gave me. She colored my hair and when she was drying it, there was absolutely no ombre effect. She told me I had two choices: to have her fix it or go home and let the color wash out. I told her that I really wanted her to fix it because it really didn't look like an ombre at all. After Karissa attempted to fix the color of my hair and gave me a "dusting" hair cut, I was really surprised that I was charged the full $145 for hair color/ombre. When I went to the front desk, there was no gift card waiting for me and when I spoke to the new spa manager Jen, she was really rude and essentially insinuated that I was trying to get free services. She stated "I looked at your record and you appear to be a good customer, so I will assume that this situation actually happened and that that maybe there should be a gift card." Who says that to any customer? And then she continued to tell me that this this not how they handle these types of issues and that if it ever happens again, I have to come back to the same stylist and let them fixed it. I told her that if that same issue ever happened again, I most certainly would not be back.
These several interactions really put a sour taste in my mouth. I wanted this to be my go-to hair place, but unfortunately, with time, the service and turn over has really caused the quality of this salon to fall, but of course, the prices only seem to go up. If you want to compete with other Cincinnati salons, you need to have far better service and managers that know how to actually provide excellent customer service. I will not be returning again.