Kay Jewelers

Got a family heirloom diamond ring resized and a diamond replaced here. The diamond is significantly smaller than the others and of completely different clarity. The ring had some sort of ugly tarnish all over the band that looked like it had sat in acid and wasn't polished afterward. The area around the diamond that was replaced is all dented and scratched up. Nice people but do yourself a favor and go somewhere else. Not happy at all.

Original review on the West Valley Utah store, also copied to South Towne in Sandy, UT and Fashion Place Mall store due to updates below. I am of frustration that I would not do business with Kay again. Too many issues and too much of a fight. Full story with updates below. The district manager in training Kelsey at Fashion Place made the previous situation right for us but ultimately it's just too much to do business with them again. In December of 2016 I bought a LeVian strawberry gold, morganite, chocolate diamond and vanilla diamond ring for $2200 (retail price is $2475) to replace my ceramic wedding band. I was told I could trade this in down the road. However, after 6 months of ruling out other issues, I discovered I was allergic to the copper in the rose (strawberry) gold ring. Kay would not allow a trade in aside from the diamond value of about $300. $300 would not replace my ring by any means. The company still sells the ring and I believe it would have been fair to offer even the sale value of the ring toward a trade in. Do not buy jewelry without a center diamond stone from Kay or you will not get anywhere near the value of your ring back if you need or want to trade this in at some point. I am left with a wedding ring that I cannot wear. Update 1/13/2018: Went into the South Towne store to have my husbands ring resized - we bought the jewelry replacement plan which will replace his ring since they can't resize it. The South Towne store told us we couldn't only do this once. The plan terms and conditions do not list only one resize and yet the store would not honor it. As you can imagine, I'm highly frustrated with Kay, yet again. I just picked up my ring from the Fashion Place site last week after having it sized smaller and it was a very poor job, uneven in the sides and a dent looking shape on the other. Update 6/29: On 6/8/2017, the Orem, UT store manager made an exception and allowed me to exchange to another LeVian ring ... if I spent $500 or more extra, which I did. I found a pretty black and white diamond band in white gold that I really liked. Later that night, I found out one of the smaller diamonds was missing so I took it to the store closer to my husbands work, South Towne Mall in Sandy, UT, to have it repaired. Yesterday, 6/28, my husband picked up the ring on his way home. The repair was shoddy work - you can tell on the edge of the band where they tried to pull the gold from the band - it's a little sharp AND they left a deep scratch further down the side of the band AND another diamond is missing (different place). Did they just take the diamond from another place and hope I wouldn't notice or is the ring that cheap in quality? I'm going back tonight in hopes to exchange to a non-LeVian ring. I'll update later. 6/29 - South Towne Mall - they were nice and helpful but ultimately suggested I go to the Fashion Place store to speak with the district manager. 6/30 - Fashion Place Mall - I worked with Kelsey and she was amazing. I did end up spending an extra $700 (above and beyond the $600 from the last trip) but I got a much better ring due to their 25% off bridal sale. Thank you Kelsey - your assistance has changed this review.

Took a bracelet for repairs. It broke the first day wearing it. $54.00 down the drain. I took another ring that had a diamond missing, it snags on everything...it has a sharp spot somewhere on the ring. DO NOT USE THEIR REPAIRS.

Don't apply for credit here if you are not wanting more than one credit inquiry on your credit report! I was told I was pre-approved which has no impact on my score since it was a pre-approval. Once I decided to go ahead and get the Kay Card I was told my credit will be ran ONCE for a decision among two different credit departments which are Comenity or Genesis. Well I got approved for credit with Genesis and I look at my credit report, to find out that my credit was ran 2 times for Comenity and once with Genesis. I called both places, the Murray store, and corporate and no one can help me with these wrongfully inquiry's that I did not authorize. Now I have to fight with the 3 credit bureaus to prove that I did not authorize all these inquiry's. If you ever dealt with Credit Dept they hate removing inquiry's! Just like a car dealership, you can't believe what you are told. They are all sells people so they don't care about your credit as long as they got an approved credit card for that day.

These guys dont know their faces from their asses! They don't do as you ask with your jewelry they do as they want, they cant give you correct info or even care about you what so ever. Ive been a long time customer with them and spent a lot of money with them! I will NEVER go through them again because how I've been treated the last several times! Shame on you Kay jewlers!! Hope you like losing customers cuz you lost me and everyone I've told about your b.s.!