Get to the top of the directory by claiming your business!
Old Mill Restaurant

Old Mill Restaurant

Claim Business
2.9 Google Review
5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville, Indiana, 47720, United States
(812) 963-6000 oldmillevansville.com
Read our review guideline

Write a Review

Loading…

Write a review
Be the first to write a review.

Google Reviews

Refresh Reviews 2.9


Apr 8, 2018
The food was good. We went for crab legs and seafood and had to wait often for them to come out. However the staff was amazing and the building historic so I enjoyed it.

Apr 7, 2018
When you walk in it’s dark and gloomy and very awkward place. It’s not very clean, the staff looks tired and gross. The food is not good either.

Feb 17, 2018
Excellent home style buffet with crab legs and prime rib. Don’t expect Golden Corral this is a private family style restaurant with lots of homemade dishes in a rustic lodge atmosphere. Restrooms could use some updating

Feb 10, 2018
Went for all you can eat seafood on a Saturday when I walked in not very warm friendly staff they look tired, overworked and later I found out understaffed. If your going just for crab legs it’s good but the rest of the sides besides fried chicken looked dried and not very appetizing the area of buffet smelled very worn out floors outdated and dark in there some of the food in there I didn’t know what it was and no labels dishes were dirty like plates with smudges glass of buffet was awful. Waiting in line every time for crabs. Honestly it was just very unsanitary like nobody gave a damn and things weren’t fresh left there and got sick tonight to my stomach half way through drive had to pull over. It’s not a clean restaurant you should see kitchen as you walk by in parking lot. God it was horrible do not eat there.

Feb 16, 2018
Nice atmosphere, good home made food. Wouldve gotten 5 stars had they not been understaffed. Only 1 waitress in the whole place

INDUSTRY BLOGS

Famous Women and the Repeal of Prohibition: Evolving Perspectives

#whiskey #smithville

While women were instrumental in initiating the Prohibition era, they also played a significant role in its repeal. The societal and cultural shifts during the 1920s and early 1930s...

Smithville Whiskey

The Science of H2O: Why Water Matters in Whisky Production

#whiskey #smithville

Water, water everywhere, but not a drop to drink? Not so in whisky production! Here's a playful dive into the scientific significance of water in crafting the spirit we all adore....

Smithville Whiskey

Carrie Nation: A Crucial Catalyst of the Temperance Movement

#whiskey #smithville

Carrie Nation, born Carrie Amelia Moore on November 25, 1846, in Garrard County, Kentucky, was a formidable figure in the American Temperance Movement, known for her audacious...

Smithville Whiskey

Bourbon: The Quintessential American Whisky with a Unique Twist

#whiskey #smithville

Hey there, whisky enthusiasts! Today, we're going to delve into a topic that's as smooth as a top-shelf dram – the unique character of bourbon whisky. Now, if you're new to the...

Smithville Whiskey

A Whiskey Journey: From Water Source to Distillery

#whiskey #smithville

Every whisky connoisseur will tell you that the secret to a great whisky lies in three key elements - grain, yeast, and water. But did you know that it's the water, often overlooked,...

Smithville Whiskey

The Earliest Instances of Whiskey in World History

#whiskey #smithville

The history of whiskey, or whisky as it's spelled in some countries, is long and somewhat shrouded in time. While the exact origins of whiskey are unclear, we can trace its ancestry...

Smithville Whiskey

Prohibition and the Transformation of Women's Social Status and Behavior in the 1920s

#whiskey #smithville

The 1920s, often referred to as the "Roaring Twenties," were a time of significant social and cultural change in the United States, particularly for women. One major element of...

Smithville Whiskey

Exploring the Spirit of America: The Kentucky Bourbon Trail and Its Impact on the Bourbon Industry

#whiskey #smithville

Hey there, bourbon lovers! Have you ever wanted to wander through the heartland of bourbon production, learn from master distillers, and sip straight from the barrel? If so, there's...

Smithville Whiskey


Own this business?

Claim Your Business
• Update your photo and information
• Get notified when reviews are posted
• Respond and manage your reviews
• Select badges and keywords

Opening Hours

Thu:5 pm - 9 pm
Fri:5 pm - 9 pm Today
Sat:5 pm - 9 pm

Restaurant Near Me

SUBWAY®Restaurants

SUBWAY®Restaurants

3200 N St Joseph Ave, Evansville
Hilltop Inn

Hilltop Inn

1100 Harmony Way, Evansville
El Charro Mexican Restaurant

El Charro Mexican Restaurant

720 N Sonntag Ave, Evansville
Arby's

Arby's

4650 University Dr, Evansville
Long John Silver's

Long John Silver's

4625 W Lloyd Expy, Evansville