Get to the top of the directory by claiming your business!
Benny's Pizza

Benny's Pizza

Claim Business
4.6 Google Review
968 Columbus Ave, Marysville, Ohio, 43040, United States
(937) 644-0881 www.bennyspizza.com
Read our review guideline

Write a Review

Loading…

Write a review
Be the first to write a review.

Google Reviews

Refresh Reviews 4.6


Mar 14, 2018
Literally the best pizza you will ever have. I moved from Ohio to Arizona quite some time ago, but I come back once to twice a year just to go to Benny's....and maybe to see my family? My husband has never experienced such great service where the waiter treated us like family upon meeting us. I love the fact that they have live music and it's a great place to party on the patio. If you aren't up to partying, you can sit inside. They have a self serve popcorn maker for while you're waiting for your pizza. I have been coming to Benny's since I was a small child. Their food is so good that they had to open a separate building just for making more pizzas and they've had several additions to their building to support more guests. Can't say enough good things about this place.

Feb 1, 2018
There is a MYSTERY that I will help solve for you at Benny’s. Ever wonder why anyone that can drive JUMPS at the opportunity to “go pick up the pizza at Benny’s”? The answer......FREE soft SELF serve ice cream while you wait for your order. Yes, this is one of few places where people are “early” to get their order and DO NOT COMPLAIN AT ALL ABOUT IT!! You can choose from the sit down restaurant but this rating is only for the pick up building (literally a separate spot). I am not a vegetable type of guy BUT you have to try the all vegetable pizza. Alarmingly amazing. The pies are thin sliced. Incredible tastes from start to finish. This is the ONLY pizza I eat as a left over (yes, sometimes for breakfast) and it DOES reheat VERY well. The traditional pepperoni is a perfectly done pie as well. Have tried about 6 versions and all are super great. So, call in your order for pick up, get there early and become part of the quietly, patiently, happy people with a big smile waiting on their pie with a cone in their hands. Cheers to ice cream and great pizza!!

Apr 30, 2018
Fantastic food. The building is pretty small and dated. I enjoyed my sit in experience except for wait staff bumping into me because my chair was near a high traffic hallway. Get the pizza, but take it home. Luckily they have two kitchens, one for carry out and the other for dine in.

May 5, 2018
There was a mistake made in our order. The restaurant and manager made it right quickly and made an adjustment to the bill without us asking. No one is perfect but the restaurant gave excellent service. It says alot about how they treated us. I would definitely go back. Highly recommend the Texas tacos and the pizza.

May 19, 2018
What a great place! The pizza was awesome. We celebrated Marshall's high school graduation and it was a blast! I'd love to go back soon.

INDUSTRY BLOGS

Whisky Wonders: An Expedition Across Regions

#whiskey #smithville

There's a world of difference between sipping a peaty Scotch, an earthy Irish whiskey, or a sweet and smoky American bourbon. These variations are not merely due to the distilleries'...

Smithville Whiskey

A Whiskey Journey: From Water Source to Distillery

#whiskey #smithville

Every whisky connoisseur will tell you that the secret to a great whisky lies in three key elements - grain, yeast, and water. But did you know that it's the water, often overlooked,...

Smithville Whiskey

The Great Whisky Adventure: A Journey Back to the Earliest Drops in History

#whiskey #smithville

Join us, dear readers, as we embark on an exciting journey back in time, tracing the footsteps of our whisky-loving ancestors! From the mystic east to the rugged Celtic lands,...

Smithville Whiskey

How to Invest in Costa Rica Real Estate

Investing in Costa Rica real estate is a structured process, but success depends on following the right steps and working with experienced professionals.

Kindred Consulting C.R.

The Evolution of Whisky: 18th Century Methods vs. Modern Mastery

#whiskey #smithville

Whisky lovers, we've got a treat for you today! We're going on a time-traveling adventure to compare whisky production methods between the 18th century and today. Understanding...

Smithville Whiskey

The Earliest Instances of Whiskey in World History

#whiskey #smithville

The history of whiskey, or whisky as it's spelled in some countries, is long and somewhat shrouded in time. While the exact origins of whiskey are unclear, we can trace its ancestry...

Smithville Whiskey

Costa Rica Residency Through Real Estate Investment

For many investors, purchasing real estate in Costa Rica is only the first step toward a larger goal—establishing residency and eventually relocating full-time. While real estate...

Kindred Consulting C.R.

Bourbon: The Quintessential American Whisky with a Unique Twist

#whiskey #smithville

Hey there, whisky enthusiasts! Today, we're going to delve into a topic that's as smooth as a top-shelf dram – the unique character of bourbon whisky. Now, if you're new to the...

Smithville Whiskey


Own this business?

Claim Your Business
• Update your photo and information
• Get notified when reviews are posted
• Respond and manage your reviews
• Select badges and keywords

Opening Hours

Mon:11 am - 11 pm Open Today
Tue:11 am - 11 pm
Wed:11 am - 11 pm
Thu:11 am - 11 pm
Sat:11 am - 1 am