Get to the top of the directory by claiming your business!
Mitchell's Fish Market

Mitchell's Fish Market

Claim Business
4.0 Google Review
185 W Waterfront Dr, Homestead, Pennsylvania, 15120, United States
Read our review guideline

Write a Review

Loading…

Write a review
Be the first to write a review.

Google Reviews

Refresh Reviews 4.0


Apr 30, 2018
Our service was very slow and unresponsive. They gave us a waitress who was clearly already overburdened by full tables when there was other wait staff who very obviously could have used more; the restaurant was not very full outside of one section. The food was not bad, but not good for the money spent and there was remarkably little of it. In my order of lobster tail and crab-stuffed shrimp, I got three rather small shrimp with a tiny amount of crab on each. My sides were some decent mashed potatoes and, get this, three stalks of asparagus. Over all, the experience was below mediocre. I would choose almost anywhere else.

Jan 27, 2018
I took my wife, son, and daughter in law here last night after many years in between visits. The environment is classy yet dimly lit. I had reservations for 715 and still needed to wait 15 min for the staff to clean a booth even though there were clearly others table options open and available. The menu is somewhat limited but offers good variety. Drink prices are quite steep. Appetizers were good. There was a significant lull in time between them and main course. When it did arrive I found the food to be quite plain. Where I was expecting, based upon the sheer price of the food, to be blown away, my party instead found our entrees to be nothing out of the ordinary. The very best item I had experienced was the jambalaya. Which was a side dish. On a good note. Our server was very friendly and attentive to our table. With all the options available in my area to eat, unless something significantly changes in the near future, I personally do not feel I will be returning back here to eat. The sheer cost of the night coupled with the ordinary taste of the food just does not warrant it.

May 13, 2018
Went there last night right before closing, which I know can be annoying for a staff ready to close. The GM greeted us and was very welcoming. Our waiter was great, food was wonderful a dm drinks were AMAZING (best in the waterfront). Really enjoyed our dinner and we were happy they didn’t make us feel like they were rushing us out or we got the last serving of food left.

Mar 2, 2018
We like Mitchell’s. Wherever we’ve visited the food has been good to great. Service has been good to great as well. For an upscale restaurant they could be a bit more focused on both consistently attentive and professional service and consistent food quality. They could achieve 5 stars with a little effort.

Nov 16, 2017
I’ve come here many times and have never had a bad meal. The fish is always cooked appropriately, and no one in my party has ever gotten ill after eating here. My four stars is because I am not partial to fish, however, my wife and mother-in-law very much enjoy coming here. The wait staff and servers are very friendly and helpful with explaining any dishes. They were also very gracious and understanding when (on a recent visit) my son spilled his water all over the table and himself. They got him clean towels to dry himself and the table. We’ll continue to come here since this is one of the better fish places in the South Hills. From late spring through early fall the outdoor patio is open and you can get good views of the Mon river rolling gently below. The Homestead Grays Bridge provides a dramatic backdrop to the scene, and the GAP (Greater Allegheny Passage) bike trail runs right next to the restaurant. Bikers often stop here for lunch.

INDUSTRY BLOGS

The Science of H2O: Why Water Matters in Whisky Production

#whiskey #smithville

Water, water everywhere, but not a drop to drink? Not so in whisky production! Here's a playful dive into the scientific significance of water in crafting the spirit we all adore. Ready...

Smithville Whiskey

Bourbon: The Quintessential American Whisky with a Unique Twist

#whiskey #smithville

Hey there, whisky enthusiasts! Today, we're going to delve into a topic that's as smooth as a top-shelf dram – the unique character of bourbon whisky. Now, if you're new to the...

Smithville Whiskey

Luxury Beachfront Homes Costa Rica for Sale

Costa Rica’s luxury real estate market has grown significantly, driven by international demand for exclusive, lifestyle-oriented properties.

Kindred Consulting C.R.

Tax Advantages of Investing in Costa Rica Property

When evaluating international real estate investments, taxation often becomes one of the most decisive factors influencing long-term returns. Costa Rica has built a strong reputation...

Kindred Consulting C.R.

Carrie Nation: A Crucial Catalyst of the Temperance Movement

#whiskey #smithville

Carrie Nation, born Carrie Amelia Moore on November 25, 1846, in Garrard County, Kentucky, was a formidable figure in the American Temperance Movement, known for her audacious...

Smithville Whiskey

Whiskeys of the World: Types and Distinctions

#whiskey #smithville

Whiskey, a beverage enjoyed globally, varies considerably in its characteristics, production methods, and styles. Different countries and regions have their unique whiskey styles...

Smithville Whiskey

The Great Whisky Adventure: A Journey Back to the Earliest Drops in History

#whiskey #smithville

Join us, dear readers, as we embark on an exciting journey back in time, tracing the footsteps of our whisky-loving ancestors! From the mystic east to the rugged Celtic lands,...

Smithville Whiskey

Mistico Costa Rica Beachfront Community Investment

The evolution of real estate investing has shifted dramatically over the past decade. Today’s investors are not simply purchasing property—they are buying into lifestyle ecosystems....

Kindred Consulting C.R.


Own this business?

Claim Your Business
• Update your photo and information
• Get notified when reviews are posted
• Respond and manage your reviews
• Select badges and keywords

Opening Hours

Mon:11 am - 10 pm Open Today
Tue:11 am - 10 pm
Wed:11 am - 10 pm
Thu:11 am - 10 pm
Fri:11 am - 11 pm
Sat:11 am - 11 pm