I've eaten here twice, and both times were disappointing. Both times I ordered a 'New York Style' pepperoni pizza and an order of fried beef ravioli.
The first time, the pizza was overcooked to the point of being burnt on the bottom, and the fried ravioli was great. NY style should have charred spots on the bottom, but the entire thing should not be black. I was disinclined to eat there again, but there is a serious lack of non-chain pizza places in Mechanicsville.
The second time, it was snowing, and I just wanted some quick pizza. I ordered fried beef ravioli and received fried cheese ravioli which wasn't as good as I remembered it being, even discounting the fact that it was the wrong dish. The pizza I received this time was undercooked to the point that the crust was doughy, and, needless to say, there were no charred bits on the bottom.
I would rather order pizza from Domino's than from here. At least at Domino's you get a consistent product. If you want a good NY style pizza, check out Two Guys in Short Pump.
