Get to the top of the directory by claiming your business!

Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club

Name: Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club
Address: 5601 Broad St, Greendale, WI, 53129, US
Telephone: (414) 858-1900
Price range: $$$

Claim Business

4.4 Google Review

Direction Bookmark

5601 Broad St, Greendale, Wisconsin, 53129, United States

(414) 858-1900 www.bartolottas.com/joey-gerards

Update Business Info | Add Verified Info

Read our review guideline

Write a Review

Loading…

Be the first to write a review.

Google Reviews

Refresh Reviews 4.4

Tony Novinska

May 8, 2018

As far as an "old-time supper club" is concerned, I suppose. But the REAL supper clubs that dot Wisconsin are not even half as expensive as this place. Don't get me wrong, it's an excellent restaurant. But the supper club vibe is meant to be repeated over and over. Growing up, I went to one in my hometown almost once a week, sometimes twice. Joey's is a destination restaurant. Our family cannot afford to eat here more than a few times per year. Love the atmosphere, the bar selection and the wait staff. I just don't think it's a pure supper club. I know, it's nit-picky, but when I think supper club, I think NOT having to pay $22 for a Lazy Susan, $8 for a salad and $40 for a Filet.

Willow Pond Apartments

Apr 1, 2018

The Easter Brunch here is rather nice. Jody, our waiter began by asking if we'd like Eggs Benedict and Mimosas. Yes please. Buffet items were wonderful with the exception of the beef which was dry. The dry beef didn't detract from the pleasant dining experience or outstanding service. Will definitely go back and will certainly request Jody!

Clancey's Chance

Jan 13, 2018

I had a gift card to burn and I spent it all here. I do not feel sad about it. The waiter we had in the bar area ( we were unable to be seated in the actual restaurant area) was just awesome. He made the whole experience even better than I expected. We got the cheese curds which were awesome. We did steak dinner for two, which the steak was definitely enough for two people, the side was a single side so that really wasn't enough for two people. But there was a mishap and they act had two accidentally bring us two sides. So we left feeling extremely full. Our waiter was also very knowledgeable about wine and drinks and drinking them was great but talking about what to order and what we were looking for was also almost better than drinking the drinks

Lucas Newkirk

Feb 24, 2018

Steak is always an excellent choice here. We've been here twice in the past month. Joey Gerard's was a common recommendation from family, friends, and work colleagues and I'm glad we listened. It's already a top 3 date place for my wife and I. If you get Matthew or Alex for servers, you'll definitely be taken care of.

Donna Yourell

May 8, 2018

Awesome restaurant!!special occasions or just a nice dinner. Matthew is great waiter and we enjoyed the wine that we had. Thanks for a great night out.

INDUSTRY BLOGS

Grain Games: The Whisky Character Playground

#whiskey #smithville

Hello, whisky wanderers! Ready to hop, skip, and jump into the rollicking world of grains and their whimsical influence on whisky character? From the robust charm of barley to the sweet...

Smithville Whiskey

Costa Rica Residency Through Real Estate Investment

For many investors, purchasing real estate in Costa Rica is only the first step toward a larger goal—establishing residency and eventually relocating full-time. While real estate...

Kindred Consulting C.R.

Bourbon: The Quintessential American Whisky with a Unique Twist

#whiskey #smithville

Hey there, whisky enthusiasts! Today, we're going to delve into a topic that's as smooth as a top-shelf dram – the unique character of bourbon whisky. Now, if you're new to the...

Smithville Whiskey

The Grain Game: How Grains Shape the Soul of Whiskey

#whiskey #smithville

Whiskey, a beloved spirit savored around the world, is a product of nature's simplest ingredients. At its heart, whiskey is nothing more than water, yeast, and most importantly,...

Smithville Whiskey

Female Bootleggers of Prohibition: Stories of Defiance

#whiskey #smithville

Prohibition, the legal enforcement banning alcohol sale and consumption in the United States from 1920 to 1933, was a unique period that saw a rise in illegal activities designed...

Smithville Whiskey

When Templates Fall Short, IOPW.com Steps In

#richmond hill #custom web develoment

Deciding on hiring someone to build out your website or choosing a template platform many others in your industry use and manage on their own is something many businesses struggle...

iOPW

Exploring the Spirit of America: The Kentucky Bourbon Trail and Its Impact on the Bourbon Industry

#whiskey #smithville

Hey there, bourbon lovers! Have you ever wanted to wander through the heartland of bourbon production, learn from master distillers, and sip straight from the barrel? If so, there's...

Smithville Whiskey