Get to the top of the directory by claiming your business!
Watermill Caterers

Watermill Caterers

Claim Business
4.4 Google Review
711 Smithtown Bypass, Smithtown, New York, 11787, United States
(631) 724-3242 www.watermillcaterers.com
Read our review guideline

Write a Review

Loading…

Write a review
Be the first to write a review.

Google Reviews

Refresh Reviews 4.4


Jun 7, 2018
I had my wedding there on 05-24-2018 the most beautiful day anyone could ask for!! If you want a have the BEST WEDDING EVER!!! The Watermill is for you. They are so easy going and amazing to work with. Shawn are maître d’ was amazing waited on us hand a foot and made everything run so easily and also always had a smile on his face. Not one minute was he miserable an Ariana, HOLY COW!! She’s the best person ever. I had a very crazy bridal party and she was on top of us all the whole night. Drinks in a hand and a huge smile on her face! She never said No and was always with me to help with my dress and my veil. She kept me calm before walking down the aisle and happy when everything went well!! Thank you watermill for having us and giving us the most amazing day ever. I wouldn’t pass it up for the world!!

Jun 5, 2018
I had my wedding at the Watermill Caterers on April 29, 2018. Back when I was venue hunting, Watermill was the first place me and my husband saw. Not knowing our budget, we weren't sure what to expect and the managers at Watermill walked us through everything. They encouraged us to look at other venues too so we could get an idea of what other venues offered... but they assured us that we would be back. And they were correct. The Watermill surpassed every venue we saw (which we saw 8) in terms of price, looks, attractiveness, food options (which are endless), and assistance. When it came time for the wedding, their staff are fast, effective, polite and treated every one of my 100 guests with the upmost care. The food was to die for. Unlike other venues that just give you three food options for you guests, the Watermill gives you 10... 10! And of course you have appetizers and desserts and the cocktail hour before it (which is an experience all on its own). If I were to pick my 2 most memorable moments of the whole experience it would be: 1) when I spilled a piece of watermelon on my white gown and my bridal assistant came running in with a tide-to-go pen - the true MVP. 2) 5 days before the wedding, the Watermill gave me and my photographer access to the whole grounds so that I could take my wedding portraits with my husband. During that time, people came to give me drinks and gave me access to the bridal suite without any additional charge. If you're looking for a venue that doesn't leave those awkward silences at weddings, gives you fast service, who are waiting for you on their hands and feet, serve amazing food and holds your hand throughout the whole experience, then the Watermill is where you go!

Jul 25, 2018
Had our wedding there July 6. They did an amazing job!!! Food was excellent and service was top notch. Did not have to think about anything! They made everything run perfectly smooth!

Jul 4, 2018
Small venue. The layout is kind of funky. Food and appetizers bar was top notch for the wedding we attended. The alter area is right by the expressway ... noise galore

May 30, 2018
My wife and I couldn't be more happy with our wedding at Watermill Caterers (4/27/18). Booking with Eric who is no longer there was a pleasure. Everything from the initial tour to discussing our options was relaxed and fun. After Eric left, Tom took over managing our date and he did a wonderful job. He made appropriate recommendations regarding our needs and never tried to up-sell us. We always felt like we were in good hands and that our requests would be met. The renovations they've done are incredible, if you're looking for clean and modern like we were this place will take your breath away. The menu options (your guests get like 10 choices...what?!) will please any crowd. We got so many compliments on the food, both for the cocktail hour and dinner. Honestly, we can't wait to be invited to a wedding here so we can enjoy it as guests too! The day of our wedding was perfect. Our maitre'd Sean was on top of everything and I'm convinced he can be in three places at once - a true professional. The bridal attendant Jessica was extremely attentive, warm, and kind. The rest of the staff was always smiling and we heard nothing but compliments from our friends and family regarding their waitstaff. They placed our decorations exactly how we wanted (even better than we had imagined in some instances!) and really make the place look amazing. We couldn't recommend this place enough. To everyone at the Watermill, THANK YOU! Megan & Lawrence

INDUSTRY BLOGS

Famous Women and the Repeal of Prohibition: Evolving Perspectives

#whiskey #smithville

While women were instrumental in initiating the Prohibition era, they also played a significant role in its repeal. The societal and cultural shifts during the 1920s and early 1930s...

Smithville Whiskey

The Evolution of Whisky: 18th Century Methods vs. Modern Mastery

#whiskey #smithville

Whisky lovers, we've got a treat for you today! We're going on a time-traveling adventure to compare whisky production methods between the 18th century and today. Understanding...

Smithville Whiskey

Female Bootleggers of Prohibition: Stories of Defiance

#whiskey #smithville

Prohibition, the legal enforcement banning alcohol sale and consumption in the United States from 1920 to 1933, was a unique period that saw a rise in illegal activities designed...

Smithville Whiskey

A Whiskey Journey: From Water Source to Distillery

#whiskey #smithville

Every whisky connoisseur will tell you that the secret to a great whisky lies in three key elements - grain, yeast, and water. But did you know that it's the water, often overlooked,...

Smithville Whiskey

Single Malt vs. Blended Whiskey: A Comprehensive Guide

#whiskey #smithville

Whether you are a whiskey connoisseur or a casual enthusiast, understanding the nuanced world of whiskey can be a delightful pursuit. Two terms that often spark curiosity are...

Smithville Whiskey

Creating Magic in a Barrel: A Step-by-Step Guide to Crafting Traditional Whiskey

#whiskey #smithville

Hello, whiskey lovers and budding distillers alike! Today, we're taking a fascinating journey into the heart of the distillery to uncover the meticulous step-by-step process of...

Smithville Whiskey

Prohibition and the Transformation of Women's Social Status and Behavior in the 1920s

#whiskey #smithville

The 1920s, often referred to as the "Roaring Twenties," were a time of significant social and cultural change in the United States, particularly for women. One major element of...

Smithville Whiskey

Carrie Nation: A Crucial Catalyst of the Temperance Movement

#whiskey #smithville

Carrie Nation, born Carrie Amelia Moore on November 25, 1846, in Garrard County, Kentucky, was a formidable figure in the American Temperance Movement, known for her audacious...

Smithville Whiskey


Own this business?

Claim Your Business
• Update your photo and information
• Get notified when reviews are posted
• Respond and manage your reviews
• Select badges and keywords

Opening Hours

Mon:9 am - 9 pm
Tue:9 am - 9 pm
Wed:9 am - 9 pm
Thu:9 am - 9 pm
Fri:9 am - 9 pm Open Today
Sat:9 am - 9 pm

Wedding Hall Near Me

Windows on the Lake

Windows on the Lake

235 Lake Shore Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma
Villa Lombardi's

Villa Lombardi's

877 Main St, Holbrook
Bourne Mansion

Bourne Mansion

500 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale
Mansion At Timber Point

Mansion At Timber Point

398 Great River Rd, Great River
Land's End Waterfront Catering

Land's End Waterfront Catering

80 Browns River Rd, Sayville